"Not Secure" Warning on Your WordPress Website: SSL and HTTPS Explained
A “Not secure” warning appears when a website is served over plain HTTP, when its SSL certificate has expired or is invalid, or when a secure page loads some items insecurely. The fix is to install or renew a valid certificate and make sure everything on the site loads over HTTPS.
What SSL and HTTPS mean
HTTPS is the secure version of the web protocol. It encrypts the connection between a visitor’s browser and your server, and it uses an SSL or TLS certificate to prove the site is genuine. Browsers show a padlock for secure sites and a warning for insecure ones. Visitors are right to be wary of a warning, especially on a page with a form or checkout.
Why the warning appears
| Cause | What you see |
|---|---|
| No certificate installed | Page served on HTTP with “Not secure” |
| Expired certificate | A full-page warning before the site loads |
| Certificate for the wrong name | Warning about a name mismatch |
| Mixed content | Padlock missing or warning though HTTPS is on |
| Redirect misconfiguration | Some pages secure, others not |
Not sure what is going on with your website?
Tell us what you are seeing and we will outline the next step before any chargeable work.
Mixed content in plain terms
Mixed content happens when a secure page loads images, scripts or styles from insecure addresses. It often follows a move to HTTPS where old content still points at http links. Browsers may block those items or show warnings. The fix is to update the old addresses in the database and settings, which should be done carefully with a backup.
Fixing it safely
- Confirm the certificate is valid and covers the exact domain
- Renew it if it is close to expiry and enable automatic renewal if available
- Make sure WordPress and Site addresses use https
- Redirect all HTTP traffic to HTTPS
- Update insecure links in content and theme settings
- Test forms, checkout and all key pages
Certificate renewals and who owns them
Many hosts provide free certificates that renew automatically, but renewals can fail silently, for example if DNS changed. Make sure someone owns the task of checking expiry dates, and consider monitoring that alerts you before a certificate lapses. A lapsed certificate can put a full warning page in front of every visitor.
Why it matters for trust and forms
A site that warns visitors is a site people leave. For forms and checkout it also matters technically: browsers may block form submissions or payment fields on insecure pages. Keeping the site fully secure protects visitors, preserves trust and avoids avoidable lost enquiries.
What visitors think when they see a warning
Most visitors do not know what an SSL certificate is. They simply see a warning that says the site is not secure or may be dangerous, and many leave immediately. For a business that depends on enquiries or sales, that is a direct loss. It also undermines trust beyond the single visit: someone who sees a warning once may remember your brand as unsafe. That is why keeping certificates valid and the site fully secure is not just technical hygiene, it is part of presenting a trustworthy business.
Automatic renewal and what can go wrong
Most certificates renew automatically, but renewals depend on conditions staying the same. If DNS changes, a verification file is removed, a security rule blocks the validation request or a hosting plan changes, the renewal can fail quietly and the certificate lapses weeks later. Setting up monitoring that alerts you before expiry, and checking after any hosting or DNS change, avoids unpleasant surprises. It is a small habit that prevents a very public failure.
Getting help
WP Mate checks certificates, redirects and mixed content as part of WordPress repair and monitors your site with every maintenance plan. If visitors are seeing warnings now, see urgent support.
Want this looked after for you?
WP Mate maintenance plans cover managed updates, daily offsite backups, security scanning and 24/7 uptime monitoring.
Not sure what's wrong? Tell us and we'll outline the next step.
Services related to this guide
WordPress repair
Broken website? We investigate the cause and fix it safely.Get a Repair Quote →
Urgent WordPress support
Website down or checkout failing? Tell us what happened.Request Urgent Help →
Talk to WP Mate
Not sure which service fits? Ask us and we will point you the right way.Contact us →
Related guides
Frequently asked questions
Is HTTPS good for SEO?
It is a lightweight ranking signal, but more importantly it protects visitors and avoids browser warnings.
Do I need to pay for an SSL certificate?
Many hosts provide free certificates. Paid options exist for specific needs.
Why does the padlock disappear on some pages?
Usually mixed content: a page loading insecure items inside a secure page.
Ready to get your website sorted?
Based in Warrnambool, Victoria, helping Australian businesses online. Tell us what is happening.
Tell your mate what's going wrong.
Send us a few details and we’ll work out the next step. Please don’t include passwords or payment details.
- Australian support in plain English
- Clear scope and next steps before chargeable work
- Backup and recovery plan before live changes
